The Netflix price increase, the “Startup Playbook”, and my own hypocrisy

Last week Netflix announced that they were increasing their prices in September. A very vocal customer base took to the internet to share its displeasure with the news. Some revolting customers even threatened to cancel their subscription unless the price increase was reversed. People were simply furious at Netflix.

“It’s ridiculous” I half-heartedly complained to a friend over lunch. “Netflix is essentially removing features and then making me pay to get them back. This whole pricing fiasco feels like they are just running an experiment on us”.

He responded “Isn’t that exactly what you teach startups to do?”. As I briefly choked on my sandwich he continued, “It’s in the Startup Playbook, right?”.

The “Startup Playbook”

My friend was referring to a common theme in startup circles: Charge more for your product. Heck, a few months ago I wrote “The audacity of charging from day one.”. The crux of my argument was to charge users early and figure out what works. Chances are you’re not going to get pricing right the first time, so experimentation is key to learning. Netflix is simply running an experiment on us by increasing their monthly fee. They might lose some customers, but overall their profits are going to skyrocket. I don’t believe their price points are perfect, but they will keep experimenting until they are.

The second reason Netflix increased their subscription fee is a bit convoluted.

Netflix has seen massive success. So much success, in fact, that the studios are getting jealous. Netflix is under immense pressure from the studios to pay more royalties and that is surely eating away at Netflix’s bottom line. Netflix is just trying to play the best it can with the cards it’s dealt. If the studios want more money, Netflix has to pass the buck.

Why the hypocrisy?

I’ve been wrestling with this for a few days and I’ve finally come to a realization: When we perceive “loss” it has a higher mental taxation. The backlash against Netflix wouldn’t have been nearly as intense if they kept the same features while increasing the price. The fact that you’d lose a feature and have to pay to get it back rubbed people the wrong way and had people grabbing their digital pitchforks.

It might make logical sense to try and split the streaming services from the DVD by mail, but humans aren’t logical creatures. For example: How many of us buy a $3 cup of coffee from Starbucks everyday yet we give pause when we’re looking at a $.99 app for our smartphones? “What if this app sucks? I’ll be down a buck and every time I see it’s icon I’ll feel stupid for buying it”. Perceived loss is a powerful feeling that can easily distort perspective.

Closing perspective

Netflix lets users watch (almost) any movie they want, whenever they want and is significantly cheaper than cable. Frankly, I find this to be incredible. I’ve decided that it’s worth it to me and I’ll be keeping it. I suspect many of the people threatening to cancel their subscriptions will ultimately come to the same realization.

  • I agree, it was more sticker shock than anything else. It’s only $15/month (try not to think about the 60% increase and you’ll be fine) which is far less than you’d spend on cable and is about equal to the price of one 3D movie ticket.

  • Even if Netflix doubled the price again, I think it would still be a great value. The problem here is people just don’t like change, especially when it comes to money.

  • rose


    The price increase is a little ridiculous. I work for DISH
    Network so I know about price increases happening, but 60 percent is a bit
    much. I know I plan on going with the cheaper company now which is going to be
    Blockbuster. They have restructured their prices and are now going to end up
    being cheaper then Netflix. You can also get more for what you pay for. You can
    get games, Blu-rays, and new releases 28 days before Netflix. With DISH you can
    get Blockbuster free for 3 months. Blockbuster is also offering Netflix
    customers a 30 day free trial with them. I like that they are rolling out all
    these deals and are coming back in the game. Go to this link to check out the
    promotion through DISH .

  • Jeremy

    The price increases is actually because they are trying to offload their less profitable DVD arm. If it was because of royalties they would charge more for their streaming service. They really want to get out of renting out DVD’s through mail.